A Tragic Holiday in Diu
Manan Vora at Kohinoor Resort on 4th Nov 2017
This is a story of a father who had to take the toughest decision of his life – to donate the organs of his only child who was brain dead due to delayed treatment for a venomous snakebite.
In the first weekend of November 2017 Himanshu Vora, a 42-year-old lawyer from Bhavnagar, Gujarat, along with his wife Nita and 10-year-old son Manan went to Diu, a union territory near Gujarat, for a holiday. The family checked into the Kohinoor Resort in Diu on Friday, 3rd Nov and were slated to check out on Sunday, 5th Nov 2017. The resort had a swimming pool and play area for kids and Manan had a very good time frolicking in the water. The family spent the entire Saturday outdoors and visited the nearby local market in the evening. During their absence the hotel room service cleaned their room and changed the bedsheets.
The family came back late on Saturday night and went to sleep. Himanshu slept with his son on the double bed and Nita slept on the extra single bed close by. Around 7.30 am on Sunday, Manan complained of pain in his right shoulder. As Manan got up, Himanshu noticed a small blood stain on the bedsheet.
Within 10 minutes, Manan complained that his vison was blurred. He then wanted to go to the toilet and while sitting on the commode he started feeling nausea. Himanshu was perplexed and started looking for an insect that may have bitten his son. He looked all around. He even pulled the bedsheets…nothing! He then moved the pillow that Manan had used. To his horror, he found a sub-adult cobra resting under the pillow that his son had used. The snake hissed in self-defense and Himanshu ran towards the bathroom shouting for help.
The room they were allotted was on the ground floor. Himanshu called out for help from the balcony of his room in response to which the hotel staff came with a snake catching stick to relocate the snake.
Himanshu and Nita immediately took Manan to the newly constructed local Govt hospital in Diu which was 5 minutes away from the resort. Doctors in the hospital examined Manan. The hospital had only one vial of antivenom which was administered to Manan. He was then referred to Una, a small town close to Diu, for further treatment. By now Manan was experiencing respiratory distress. The hospital staff frantically looked for the driver of the ambulance parked in its compound. They were able to trace him only after 45 minutes. By then precious time was lost.
The ambulance that arrived to take Manan had an oxygen cylinder but no oxygen mask. Due to this, Manan was not given ventilatory support while being transported. By now, Manan was suffering immense respiratory distress.
Himanshu was uncontrollably distressed and tried reaching as many people as possible who could help to save his son. The ambulance reached Una around 9 am. Manan was admitted with cardiac arrest. Dr Divyakant Solanki immediately resuscitated him and put him on life support. They then administered 10 vials of antivenom and another 6 vials after 6 hours. The doctors and Manan’s family waited for him to revive after he received treatment. Hours passed but Manan did not revive consciousness.
After 24 hours of admission at the hospital in Una, doctors treating Manan informed the family that the patient was stable and his heart was functioning normally but there was no brain activity. By now Himanshu’s extended family had arrived at Una.
Manan needed to be in a hospital where they could carry out further tests. The doctors discharged him late night on 6th Nov and he was rushed to a hospital in Bhavnagar in the wee hours of 7th Nov, 2017. A CT scan at the Bhavnagar hospital showed no brain activity. On 8th Nov, the treating doctor approached the parents to counsel them about the condition of their brain-dead child and whether they wished to donate his organs. Himanshu and Nita were horrified at this suggestion and questioned the doctor’s ethics for suggesting such a plan when it could be seen clearly that their son’s heart was functioning normally.
It took some convincing and eventually the parents decided to donate their son’s organs. Manas’s liver was given to a 65-year-old male patient from Ahmedabad. His kidneys were donated to a 44-year male from Baroda and a 49-year male patient from Morbi (near Rajkot).
Manan was born on 2nd March 2007 and died on 9th Nov 2017. He was a foodie, loved to draw and enjoyed swimming. Besides cricket, he was also good at math. He was unsure whether he should be a pilot or a chartered accountant when he grew up.
It was hard for Manan’s parents to cope with his loss. Eventually they visited each of the three organ recipients and continue to keep in touch with them on a regular basis.
It is six months since Manan’s death. Everyday his parents begin their day by remembering how they spent their last few days with Manan. The self-searching journey of the grieving parents continues.
The resort staff were well aware of the presence of snakes on their property and had snake handling equipment to relocate / catch snakes. How ever there was no signs of safety nor preparedness in a case of emergency in a snakebite situation. To compound the issue, the hospital in Diu did not have a stock of snake antivenom. While the hospital was a newly constructed facility having OT (Operation Theatre), it was not equipped to handle snakebite cases. Considering the fact that there is a healthy distribution of venomous snakes in Diu, it is but logical that both, the resort and the local hospital should have been equipped to handle such situations.
Manan didn’t die from snakebite; Absence of snake antivenom killed him!
Written by Priyanka Kadam (as narrated by Himanshu & Nita Vora).
Umang Pandya
May 12, 2018 at 06:02 pmGreat article!!..
Jill Vora
May 12, 2018 at 06:17 pmAbsolutely true and a greatly written article.
Vipul vora
May 12, 2018 at 06:34 pmReal feeling that what is life? Or what meaning of life we lost our nephew but three people get new life but we must think about awareness of hotel or hospital negligence to hunt a boy
Himanshu vora
May 12, 2018 at 09:04 pmOur lives are destroyed.. Please pray for my son Manan.. May his shoul rest in peace
Niki parekh
May 13, 2018 at 02:33 amWe all miss you manan.
Siva Sanjeev
May 13, 2018 at 03:45 amBasic medical first aid is a bare minimum necessity. Really unfortunate that the hospitals lack anti venom vials (I guess it’s the polyvalent anti venom that’s used to treat all the big four bites, in India). Not able to treat the patient because of unavailability of medicine in a medically advanced country like India, that too in a tourist location is something we need to be ashamed of. This is not some way off village for God’s sake.
The decision taken by Manan’s parents is hard and I pray that no parent should go through such an ordeal. Manan lives on with his organs donated.
Harshil shah
May 13, 2018 at 04:27 amIt is such a great loss.. Decision of donating organs was such a noble cause and manan saved life of three.. we hope that after this incident, local hospital and hotels would be well equipped with such medical treatments..
Jiten Chhagani
May 13, 2018 at 05:08 amNo words to say for the father who has taken ultimate decision in his life of donating the organs of his only son and that to in a critical condition as narrated above. God bless him.
As for Manan, it is hard to believe that the naughty boy is no more. God bless the soul.
Purvi Shah
May 13, 2018 at 06:18 amManan was a champion. He lost his life but saved 3 people’s lives. Hats off to the parents who took such decision.
We hope now after this hospital and hotel management should care of their patients and guests and would have proper medicines n equipments. God bless.
Milan patel
May 13, 2018 at 06:20 amMay his soul rest in peace
Dr prashant shihora
May 13, 2018 at 06:56 amEye opener for all.
Jayesh Soni
May 13, 2018 at 08:22 amIt was truely the most tragic experience for all of us…..but we must say BRAVO….to the brave parents whose timely decision gave life to three people.
Manan we all miss you so much.
Jaysukh Kalathiya
May 14, 2018 at 04:48 amMay the soul rest in peace
Bravo……parents
Nita vora
Oct 18, 2018 at 08:30 pmWe Lost our son for such a negligence of hotel owner and staff..and also diu government hospital and their doctor… for not provide proper treatment to my son..very big hospital!!!!!!! But not a single antivenom…for government .. tourist places r not safe..do needful to tourist ..that they didn’t pass in our situation..
Surya Rao
Aug 02, 2019 at 03:51 amGreat loss for your family that no one can even begin to understand. May God give you peace. The resort must be taken to court to ensure this never happens to anyone again.
Respect for you both and Manan for giving life to 3 people